Detailed Voting Results - Veteran Teams
  2013 SCGFFL Rule Change Voting                                                 SO BB SV RT DA MB DB SF PM DH GI JB SP MC SM RB JW VE NB AD SG LL RA JM
                                                              1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
              L  
Version:   2.1               a  
Voting Status: == Voting Complete ==   B     D S S   V A   w  
Voting Closes On: 21-Jul-2013   h     e a u   i b   r  
  a     S V n M s   l r   e  
Last Upate Date:  22-Jul-2013   s S     t i c a t W l N a   n  
Number of Proposals on Ballot in 2013:          19   i i     u t h h e u a e h   c  
  n s     a o e b r l d l a   e  
  == t   D r == z u == l a l m ==  
  B o     t H == b M s ==   == L A  
  h ==   B == a P a c L c E B D G a l  
  a V   r F M m e n L u h s r e u w m M
  r a   i l u i B d i e e l c i l n r s a
  w u   A B s a n l I e r == l d e o s g n e t r
S a g R k u a s r t m a o C l t g b a a a n r t
P n h J i c r c o o a l z o a k e a r d l c o i
O i t T n k d h e n i e a x n e r r d o a e m n
Voting Percentage --> 95% ALL ALL 5% ALL ALL 5% 58%   ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL  
               
  ITEMS BEING VOTED ON FOR 2013 SEASON                                                                                                      
                   
 Financials & Fees                                                         SO BB SV RT DA MB DB SF PM DH GI JB SP MC SM DL JW VE NB AD SG LL RA JM  
                   
F.01 SCGFFL Fines as a Result of NFL Fines                                                
            Submitted By: Munroe & SPO ('12)                                                
    Each SCGFFL owner would be obligated to pay a fine into the SCGFFL RESULT:  FAILED                                                
    pot if an NFL player on their team is assesed a fine by the NFL.  Rate 2     Adopt this Method   SO           PM                                
    would be $1 for every $1000 of NFL Player fine. 11                       Reject this Method   BB RT   MB DB         JB SP MC     JW VE NB AD          
                                                                 
 The Draft                                                             SO BB SV RT DA MB DB SF PM DH GI JB SP MC SM DL JW VE NB AD SG LL RA JM  
                   
D.01 Adopt Kentucky Derby Selection Process for determining Draft Order RESULT:  FAILED                                        
            Submitted By: Munroe ('10) 4               Adopt this Method   RT   PM     MC   AD    
    Traditionally, the random drawing for draft spots has meant that each owner 9                         Reject this Method   SO BB   MB DB   JB SP JW VE NB      
    is assigned a draft position based upon a number drawn out of a hat.           Undecided                  
    This proposal would change that method.   The random drawing would still occur,                                                      
    with Owners 1 through 12 being drawn randomly.  The first owner drawn from the                                                      
    hat would then have 24 hours from the email announcing the results of the drawing                                                      
    to announce which draft order position they wish to draft from.   After                                                        
    their choice is announced to the league, the next owner drawn would then have                                                      
    24 hours to announce which of the remaining spots they wish to draft from.   This                                                      
    process would continue (in both Conferences) until all 12 owners have chosen                                                      
    their draft position for the year.  If an Owner allows 24 hours to elapse without                                                      
    announcing their position when it is their turn, then they will be assigned the                                                         
    lowest remaining Round 1 draft position, and the process will continue with                                                         
    the next owner.                                                             
                                                                 
D.02 DRAFT LOCATION FOR 2014                                                                        
            Submitted By: SCGFFL ('13)   RESULT:  VEGAS                                              
    Where should the draft be held in 2014? 8                               Las Vegas SO RT MB DB   SP MC JW VE        
              0                               Boston                        
              2                               New Orleans           NB AD      
              1                               Miami Beach BB                  
              1                               Abstain             JB            
                                                                 
WIN / LOSS RECORDS (League Management & Administration)                                                     SO BB SV RT DA MB DB SF PM DH GI JB SP MC SM DL JW VE NB AD SG LL RA JM  
                   
                   
W.01 Modify how Wins and Losses are assigned   RESULT:  FAILED                                          
            Submitted By: Munroe ('12) 3     *                         Adopt this Rule RT MB   PM            
              10                               Reject this Rule SO BB   DB   JB SP MC JW VE NB AD    
    NOTE:  Only if supported by software                                                                    
                                                                                 
    Proposal would award additional WIN's and LOSS's to an Owners record based                                                                  
    upon where they finish each week in the total points for the week ranking.                                                                      
    Teams finishing in the top 50% of the rankings would receive an additional                                                                    
    WIN, and teams finishing in the bottom 50% would receive an additional loss.                                                                   
    Only 1 additional W or L would be awarded to each team each week, regardless                                                                  
    of whether the week is a Double Header week for Head to Head games.                                                                     
                   
 Rosters & Roster Management                                                       SO BB SV RT DA MB DB SF PM DH GI JB SP MC SM DL JW VE NB AD SG LL RA JM  
                   
R.01 R.01 Restrict Suspended Players from SCGFFL I/R Eligibility                                                                                                      
            Submitted By: Akin ('13)   RESULT:  FAILED                                                                            
    Players suspended by the NFL or by their NFL team would no longer be 5                               Adopt this Rule         DA             JB SP         VE NB            
    eligible to be placed on the SCGFFL I/R section of owners' rosters 9                               Reject this Rule SO BB   RT   MB DB   PM         MC     JW     AD          
                                                                                                                   
                   
R.02 R.02 Marshawn Lynch Rule                  
  Submitted By: Munroe ('13)                  
  Owners would have the ability to designate starter backups which would RESULT:  FAILED                  
  be auto-inserted into lineups if their 1st choice is declared inactive on  3       Adopt this rule RT DB PM            
  gameday 10                     Reject this rule SO BB   MB     JB SP MC JW VE NB AD    
                   
R.03 R.03 Fee for lineup submissions of less than 9 starting players                  
  Submitted By: Stuart ('13)                  
  $10 Fee and an automated update to 9 players for teams which submit RESULT:  FAILED                  
  less than 9 players in their starting lineup, and also an automatic 6             Adopt this rule   DB SF   JB SP   NB AD    
  modification to lineup to get it to 9 players 8                 Reject this rule SO BB RT MB   PM     MC JW VE      
                   
                   
 Scoring Change Proposals                                                       SO BB SV RT DA MB DB SF PM DH GI JB SP MC SM DL JW VE NB AD SG LL RA JM  
                   
S.01 Home vs Away Designation for Playoffs                  
  Submitted By: SPO ('11) RESULT:  FAILED                  
  Allow Playoff teams to earn Home Field Advantage based upon their 5           Adopt this rule SO BB RT DB   JB          
  seeding, giving them a +2 point advantage in their playoff game. 8                 Reject this rule   MB   PM   SP MC JW VE NB AD    
  Would be valid for all playoff games EXCEPT the Championship                  
  Game.                  
                   
S.02 All Scores in OT receive 50% Scoring Bonus                    
  Submitted By: SPO ('11) RESULT:  FAILED                  
  Any Scoring Play (not yardage points) recieves a 50% bonus 2     Adopt this rule SO           NB      
  if it occurs in Overtime of an NFL Game 10                     Reject this rule BB RT MB DB   JB SP MC JW VE AD    
                   
                   
S.03 Penalties for Lousy DEF Units                  
  Submitted By: Munroe ('13) RESULT:  FAILED                  
  2     Adopt this rule   MB   PM            
  11                       Reject this rule SO BB RT DB   JB SP MC JW VE NB AD    
                   
S.04 Punt Return Yardage Scoring                  
  Submitted By: Munroe ('13) RESULT:  FAILED                  
  4         Adopt this rule   DB PM     MC   NB      
  8                 Reject this rule SO BB RT MB     JB   JW VE AD    
                   
S.05 QB Penalty for Pick Six Interceptions                  
  Submitted By:  Munroe ('13) RESULT:  PASSED                  
  7               Adopt this rule RT DB PM   JB SP   NB AD    
  6             Reject this rule SO BB   MB       MC JW VE      
                   
                   
S.06 Kicker Yardage Bonus Modification   RESULT:  FAILED                                          
            Submitted By: Munroe ('13) 5                               Adopt this rule RT DB PM   JB     NB      
    K's would earn a long yardage bonus of 0.1 points per yard for any made 8                               Reject this rule SO BB   MB     SP MC JW VE AD    
    FG over 50 yards                                                                        
                                                                                 
  RESULT:  FAILED                  
S.07 Kicker Scoring - Clutch Submitted By: SPO ('12) 3       Adopt this rule SO   MB     JB          
  Double Points for Game Winning FG's kicked with 2:00 or less on clock 8                 Reject this rule BB   DB   SP MC JW VE NB AD    
  1   Abstain   RT              
                   
S.08 Clutch Scores - Skill Position Players RESULT:  FAILED                  
  Submitted By: SPO ('12) 2     Adopt this rule SO         MC        
  Double Points for any Game Winning TD based scores by skill position  10                     Reject this rule BB RT MB DB   JB SP JW VE NB AD    
  players with 2:00 or less remaining on clock                  
                   
S.09 Fix the anomoly which includes Pts against ST units in "Defensive Points Allowed" Calculation                  
  Submitted By: SCGFFL ('13) RESULT:  PASSED                  
  Fix this anamoly 8                 Adopt this rule SO BB   MB DB   JB SP   NB AD    
  3       Reject this rule         MC JW VE      
  1   Abstain   RT              
                   
  RESULT:  PASSED                  
S.10 Fluffer Award Rule Submitted By: Beale ('13) 9                   Yes   SO BB RT MB DB   JB   MC   NB AD    
  Adopt the "Fluffer" Award for teams surrendering the most points 3       No         SP JW VE      
                   
                   
 Post Season Proposals                                                         SO BB SV RT DA MB DB SF PM DH GI JB SP MC SM DL JW VE NB AD SG LL RA JM  
                   
P.01 Changes to awards for Loser Tournament                                                                    
            Submitted By: Bharwani ('13)   RESULT:  PASSED                                          
    Give a 6th Round Pick to Winner, instead of an 8th Round Pick 7                               Adopt this rule SO BB RT DB   JB SP MC        
    Give a 12th Round Pick to Runner Up (currently they get Zilch) 4                               Reject this rule   MB       JW VE AD    
              1                                                             NB      
                   
P.02 Mirror NFL Seeding Method for Division Winners   RESULT:  PASSED                                          
            Submitted By: Bharwani ('12) 8                               Adopt this rule BB RT MB DB   JB SP MC   AD    
    The 3 Division Winners in each Conference automatically receive 4                               Reject this rule SO         JW VE NB      
    the top 3 seeds in their Conference and the Wildcard Team                                                                     
    automatically receives the last seed in the Conference playoffs                                                                    
                                                                                 
                                                                                                                   
PRIOR YEARS VOTING KEY
See Results of  2012 Rule Change Voting   - Team has voted FOR this proposal or this option
See Results of  2011 Rule Change Voting   - Represents 1/2 a vote for the proposal - Dual Owner Team with owners voting for opposing options
See Results of  2010 Rule Change Voting * - Conditional Vote FOR proposal.  Conditioned upon ability of League Software to support the change
See Results of  2009 Rule Change Voting   - Team has voted AGAINST this proposal
See Results of  2008 Rule Change Voting   - Represents 1/2 a vote against the proposal - Dual Owner Team with owners voting for opposing options
See Results of  2007 Rule Change Voting
  - Team voted to abstain or Team Indicated no preference on vote
u - Undecided.  Team has indicated intent to vote, but is still considering opinion on issue
  - No vote received from this team on this item
  - New Team for 2010, did not get deposit on file prior to Off Season Owner Meeting, was ineligible to vote Team is Ineligible to vote on this item 
  -  New Team for 2013, did not get deposit on file prior to close of voting period, was ineligible to vot'e
  - Team did not register a vote on issue prior to voting period closing